Xcel Energy Center vs. the Verizon Center: a hockey comparative study
Feb 16th 2008tbHockey & Sports & Thoughts
We recently took in another hockey game to see the Caps take on the Rangers. Not a bad game. However the longer I watched it, the more I longed and pined for “the X”, a fine place to watch hockey. It made me think though what was it that I preferred. Was it simply the fact that I’m a Wild fan and more comfortable in more friendly confines added to the fact that I can’t find myself hopping on the Caps fan-base anytime soon? [1] Or was it something else, something a little more about the venue itself that I didn’t like. There’s maybe some truth to that fact because we did happen to watch a Hoyas game there once and I really enjoyed it. Still, that doesn’t quite ring true to me though.
Set aside my dislike for the hometown team, what was it about the rink? Like the Xcel Energy Center, it is built in a similar way. I was trying to find anything that linked the two as I thought I remembered construction of the X was loosely based on VZC, but I couldn’t find anything to confirm that fact. But let me point out my pet peeves of VZC.
First of all, the ice is bad. You can tell, even from the second deck, that the ice is chippy, soft and has got to be a pain in the ass for the players (both home and away) to skate upon [2]. Bad ice is dangerous to players and really makes for bad hockey. Even the Caps players have difficulty with it for as many times as I’ve seen pucks skip over their sticks.
Secondly, the sound system. If anyone at VZC cruises blogs or whatever and notices this (fat chance though), please tell them to notch down the speakers so your rib cage doesn’t rattle every time there happens to be bass in a song. It’s far too loud, and it’s too loud in proportion to actual noise from the game. What’s exciting in hockey is feeling the energy of the crowd, the noise and the intensity as the game progresses. That illusion is shattered when this jarring, crushing noise blares from the speakers, forcing any conversation you are having with anyone near you to be continued in shouting tones. But when play starts, the music dies and you are left with the silence of the crowd hushed and watching the game. It is deeply anticlimactic. The X has great acoustics so they can play the music, they can do the “fire the home team up” bit but in a way that makes the start of play not as shocking.
Other complaints are ones of arena “attitude”. I’m not really referring to the fans. Some of them are very vocal, very “homerific” and that’s to be expected [3]. No, it’s little things that don’t really add up to a hockey atmosphere. How about letting the organ play a bit more instead of the music blaring a bunch of garbage (to give them their due, they do play “Good Ol’ Hockey Game” at every match, so props to them for that song). Apparently, the crowd is also easily influenced by some poor sap with an air horn. Three short honks and the “Let’s go Caps” chants come out. That’s fine. But every seven to fifteen minutes? And every time someone starts an opposing chant for the visitors? Hey, face it, sometimes you’re not the most favored team, even on your own ice. I think the Pens game proved that.
Also, and this is a criticism of a lot of teams and especially in hockey, but can we drop the stupid compilation of inspiring speeches from sports movies crammed and spliced together and played at “pivotal” points at the end of the game? Every team does this and it annoys me a bit whenever I see it. I’ve only seen a couple really clever uses in all the games I’ve seen. But I’ve seen three Caps games, and three times now, there’s this dreadful mashup of these movie clips which is utterly horrible. It’s not clever. I’ve seen much better work on YouTube by people who do it for a lark and not get paid for it. Frankly, I find it a bit embarrassing for the home team. Taking inspiring coach speeches from inspiring sports films, clips from the classic movie “Network” and some God-awful Tom Green clip, thrown into a video food processor and spat out is no way to fire the home crowd up.
I feel good about getting this off my chest. I doubt any change will come to VZC, even if I would’ve typed up my grievances and shot them off to Ted Leonsis himself. But airing something like this is at least cathartic and I will sleep better for doing so.
- “There’s a lot here also that remind me about watching the Seattle Mariners as well. That city is all about Ichiro and the Caps are all about Ovechkin. They are both team games and their promotions should be about the team, not just these obviously talented players. But what do you do…these two are getting paid the big bucks.”
- “There is evidence that some attention is being paid to this, as found in a post from the team owner back in December about the bad ice and injuries on his team. Personally, I’ve always found it a bit too warm in that arena. Lowering the arena temperature by 5° would likely help as well as doing something about the humidity.”
- “Note that fans here on the East coast just aren’t as friendly. You want to ask about a player and maybe strike up some hockey conversation, hope you brought a friend who’s willing to chat. East-coasters just won’t respond to you, or if they do, grudgingly. At the X, it was easy—in the second deck at least—to chat hockey with knowledgeable fans. I miss that too, but it is a bit biased toward general coastal attitudes.”
